Home › Resources › Storm Damage Restoration

Working with Adjusters After a Storm: What to Say, What to Show

The adjuster visit is the pivotal moment in your storm damage claim. The scope and valuation established during that inspection determines what your insurer will pay — and correcting an incomplete scope afterward requires significantly more effort than getting it right the first time. Knowing how adjusters work, what they look for, and how to present your documentation positions you to advocate effectively for a complete and accurate claim.

Adjusters come in two varieties, and knowing which type you’re dealing with matters. Staff adjusters are employees of your insurance company, typically salaried, and handle claims exclusively for that insurer. Independent adjusters (IAs) are contractors who work for multiple insurance companies on a per-claim basis. They’re commonly deployed during large catastrophe events — a major hailstorm across DFW, for example — when the volume of claims exceeds the insurer’s staff adjuster capacity.

Independent adjusters vary significantly in experience, local market familiarity, and inspection thoroughness. A staff adjuster in Dallas has typically inspected hundreds of Texas roofs; an IA dispatched from out of state after a major storm event may be less familiar with Texas-specific roofing practices, local material costs, and the specific damage signatures of the hail size that hit your neighborhood. This doesn’t make IAs adversaries — most are professional and thorough — but it means you may need to provide more context and documentation during the inspection.

A third option is a public adjuster (PA) — an independent professional you hire to represent your interests in a claim. Public adjusters work on a contingency fee (typically 10–15% of the claim settlement) and advocate for the highest complete and accurate settlement. They’re most appropriate for large or complex claims where significant money is at stake and the initial adjuster estimate is substantially below contractor quotes.

Before the Adjuster Arrives

Preparation before the inspection is where claims are won or lost. Most homeowners show up to their own adjuster appointment with nothing — no documentation, no contractor report, no photo record. That puts the entire scope determination in the adjuster’s hands. A prepared homeowner is a different conversation.

The preparation checklist:

Build your photo file. Timestamped photos of every damage area you can safely observe from ground level, plus soft metal surfaces (AC fins, gutters, screens) and any visible structural damage.
Get an independent contractor inspection first. A licensed roofing contractor’s written inspection report, documenting damage with photographs and a scope of work estimate, gives the adjuster professional corroboration. It also gives you a comparison baseline if the adjuster’s scope is significantly different.
Pull the NOAA storm data. The NOAA Storm Events Database allows you to search by county and date for documented storm events including hail size and wind speed. Printing the relevant event data for your county and date gives the adjuster a quick reference and demonstrates that you’ve verified the storm occurred.
Know your policy basics. Have your declarations page accessible. Know your Coverage A limit, your deductible structure (flat dollar vs. percentage, AOP vs. wind/hail), and whether you have replacement cost value (RCV) or actual cash value (ACV) coverage.
Document interior damage. Any water staining on ceilings, wet insulation, damaged drywall, or damaged flooring from water intrusion should be photographed and documented. Interior damage is often part of the same claim and the adjuster should document it.

Be present for the adjuster’s inspection. This is not optional. Adjusters who inspect alone without the homeowner present are more likely to produce incomplete scopes — not necessarily from bad intent, but because there’s no one to show them the AC fins, point out the interior water stain, or walk them to the area of the roof that had three shingles blow off. Your presence ensures nothing is missed by omission.

Accompany the adjuster throughout. If they’re on the roof, you can be at ground level ready to ask questions. If they’re on a ladder, be there when they come down.
Point out all documented damage areas. Show your photo documentation. Point out soft metal impacts. Walk them to the interior water staining.
Ask what they’re documenting. It’s appropriate to ask “are you noting the damage to the ridge cap?” or “did you see the impact on the gutters?” You’re not challenging them — you’re ensuring completeness.
Note what they inspect and what they skip. Write down the areas they examined and the areas they didn’t. This becomes useful if you need to dispute scope gaps.

“The most important thing a homeowner can do during an adjuster visit is bring a contractor with them. Not to argue with the adjuster, but because two sets of professional eyes on the same roof almost always catch more than one. And when there’s a scope gap, the contractor can speak to it on the spot rather than having to file a supplement later.”

What to Show Your Adjuster

Present your documentation in a specific order designed to build the adjuster’s confidence in the validity and extent of the claim.

Start with the NOAA data. “Here’s the documented hail event for our county on [date] — 1.75-inch hail.” This establishes the event’s existence with a third-party source independent of both you and your contractor.
Show ground-level soft metal impacts. Walk them to the AC condenser and the gutters before anything else. These are the easiest damage indicators for adjusters to verify and they establish that the hail event was real and of significant size.
Present your photo file. Organized by location (slope, ridge, penetrations), with timestamps visible. Let the adjuster scroll through it rather than narrating each image.
Present the contractor report last. “We had a licensed contractor inspect before you arrived — here’s their report and scope estimate.” This is a comparison baseline, not a challenge. Frame it as “I want to make sure we’re looking at the same damage.”

If the Scope Is Incomplete

Receiving an adjuster estimate that is materially lower than your contractor’s estimate is common, not unusual. The most frequent scope gaps involve understated square footage, missing starter and drip edge line items, reuse noted on flashings that need replacement, and omitted interior damage. When you identify a gap, the process is:

Request a reinspection in writing. Contact your claims representative (not just the adjuster) by email and specify the exact scope items you believe are incomplete. Written communication creates a record.
Provide contractor documentation of the disputed items. “The adjuster noted flashing reuse; our contractor’s report states the step flashing at the chimney has failed seal and requires replacement. Here is the photo documentation.” This is not a complaint — it’s a scope addendum backed by professional documentation.
Request the reinspection within your state’s claim handling timeline. Texas, Colorado, Kansas, and Missouri all have statutory claim handling timelines that insurers are required to meet. Texas Insurance Code Chapter 542 requires insurers to begin investigating a claim within 15 days of receipt.

When additional damage is discovered during the repair process that was not included in the original adjuster estimate — damaged decking, failed sheathing, additional flashing failures — this becomes a supplemental claim. Contractors who work regularly with insurance claims are experienced in the supplement process. Pro Exteriors documents discovered scope changes with photographs, item-by-item documentation, and a formal supplement request submitted to your claims representative before the additional work is performed.

The supplement process is legal, standard practice, and explicitly anticipated in your policy language. An insurer who refuses to consider supplements for documented additional damage may be engaging in bad faith claims handling — a pattern that state insurance commissioners take seriously. Keep all supplement documentation and communications in writing.

Need a Contractor for Your Adjuster Visit?

Pro Exteriors attends adjuster inspections across DFW, Denver, Wichita, and Kansas City with professional documentation that gets complete scopes written the first time.

Hail Damage on a Roof: How to Identify It Before Your Adjuster Arrives

How to File a Roof Insurance Claim: The Complete Step-by-Step Guide

Wind Damage vs. Hail Damage: How to Tell the Difference

For the service page this article supports, see storm damage roof repair.